Hi Paul - I was around when Geoff's class was very much a traditional Shotokan Karate class - back in the early 80's
Training in a roller skating hall in Longford (Les Allen's Billiard Hall)
We had quite large numbers back then - even though the training was pretty tough.
Probably a regular 40 attendees to each session but a general membership of well over that.
I was also there when the club moved to different locations including Foxford School, AT7, back to Foxford School, then up to 6 nights per week, training at several locations in order to try to attract different students from different areas of the city.
One venue was the old co-op hall which is now Glen Smith's excellent Red Corner - although it was only a bare wooden floored hall when we were there.
The training had become particularly tough by this point and I remember quite a few occasions where it was just me, Geoff and Sharon turning up to the Co-op hall.
So, one extreme to the other - but I think alot of it was that we were wanting to train 6 nights per week but alot of the students didn't want to - and there's obviously nothing wrong with that.
I guess a problem we all have to deal with as instructors is that often our priorities with regards to training are different to our students.
And I think this goes for everyone we deal with regardless of the situation - judging and expecting others to deliver to our own standards not theirs!
The main lessons learned was that, if you have a tough, realistic, honest club that wants to pressure test at a high level - you're not going to keep many students.
Things have now done a ful circle for Geoff though because now people are queing up to train with him again.
Partly because he has moved on from the real heavy stuff, but also because of his level of expertise.
I dare say, even if Geoff resurrected animal days on his seminars, he'd still have a long queue of people wanting to train.
Not sure if that answers the original question though
Cheers
AL